Scope: PC 1.0 series, standard world settings, no mods. This assumes a solo first encounter with a 0-star troll. Starred enemies and fights inside caves are not assumed to be manageable with the same preparation.

How to choose a bow, spear, or shield

OptionHow to use it in a first fightWhat to watch for
BowKeep distance and shoot after an attackHolding a draw drains stamina needed for movement and dodging.
SpearDodge an attack, then make a short thrustWatch for the next move even while close; do not spend all stamina attacking.
Mace or other blunt weaponReconsider it before making it your main weapon against a trollTrolls resist blunt damage and are weak to pierce.
ShieldChoose based on your experience and the shield you haveDo not assume that carrying one will block a heavy hit.

A Finewood Bow or a full set of bronze gear is not mandatory from the start. First check that your bow is repaired and you have arrows, and that you have food and an escape route. If you choose a spear, keeping it in hand for short counters can mean less swapping than throwing it and chasing it down.

If you still need early food or a bow, return to preparing for the first Eikthyr fight (Japanese article). You do not need to try this while low on food or surrounded by other enemies.

Fists and logs have different attack patterns

Troll and tellAttack that followsResponse
Unarmed troll approaches while moving an armPunchDo not keep drawing your bow within reach; dodge, then counter.
Unarmed troll raises an arm highGround slamStop attacking as you see the wind-up; move away or dodge as it lands.
Unarmed troll at a distanceRock throwDo not assume you are safe at range; move when you see the throw.
Troll swings a log sidewaysHorizontal sweepDo not rely on a small sidestep; leave the attack area or dodge.
Troll raises a logVertical slamDo not keep attacking from the front; dodge the slam, then reassess.

Dodging is not about rolling repeatedly the moment an arm goes up. Time it to the attack, and do not immediately return to a long attack chain afterward. If you changed your key bindings, test them somewhere safe before fighting. PC version 1.0.14 also added an alternative key binding dedicated to dodge.

Six steps from first sighting to counterattack

  1. Decide whether to fight or retreat first. If the troll has stars, you are low on food or arrows, or several enemies are nearby, create distance instead of starting the first fight.
  2. Check your way back. Avoid places where trees or ledges can trap your movement. Choose a route that does not lead the troll straight to your base, ship, or portal.
  3. Check whether it is unarmed or carrying a log. Watch its weapon and arm movement, and focus first on dodging one attack.
  4. Counter briefly after an attack. Limit how long you draw the bow, or avoid greedy spear combos. Stop attacking when the next arm movement begins.
  5. Rest your weapon when stamina is low. Do not stack running, drawing the bow, and dodging; recover enough stamina to respond to the next attack.
  6. Reassess if another enemy or terrain change appears. If a Greydwarf or other enemy joins in, prioritize retreat instead of focusing only on the troll. Regroup somewhere safe, restore food, arrows, and durability, then try again.

Troll attacks can damage trees and buildings. Do not treat a tree or small hut as automatically safe cover, and account for fallen trees or broken walls changing your route. Trying to kill a troll from behind your base wall can put the place you need to return to at risk.

If you cannot win, review retreat conditions before attack count

What is going wrongHow to reset the fight
Stamina runs out while fleeing with the bow drawnStop attacking and recover room to move and dodge first.
A shield block causes a heavy staggerDo not repeat the same block; return to dodging the attack.
A log sweep catches youStop relying on a small sidestep; check its reach and next swing.
A tree or building breaks and blocks the routeStop shooting in place and use the alternate escape route you checked.
You are fighting a starred troll or reinforcements tooSeparate that from preparation for one 0-star troll and leave the fight.

Do not assume that simply creating distance always ends pursuit. Check the troll’s location before returning to your base. For a first encounter, surviving and getting home after learning its attacks can be a good goal instead of insisting on a kill.

After a kill, check the area before collecting drops. Your next Black Forest goal can be gathering Surtling Cores in Burial Chambers or, if you are ready, the first Elder fight (Japanese article).

If you want to learn shield controls, practice when to block normally and when to parry against weaker enemies first.

Sources and references

Questions and contributions

Share questions, corrections or play reports. Only approved posts for this article and language appear here.

Submit for review

Do not include personal details, passwords or private information about others. Text only. Publication and replies are not guaranteed.