This guide covers the PC 1.4.5 series with no mods. It helps you choose an initial accessory modifier and decide whether to try reforging at a small cost. Use it after rescuing the NPC and finishing any accessory combinations you plan to make.

Separate crafting at a workbench from asking the NPC to reforge

Talk to the Goblin Tinkerer and choose “Reforge.” This is not a crafting action performed at the Tinkerer’s Workshop.

If the Goblin Tinkerer has not moved in yet, first follow How to rescue him in the Caverns and have him move in. Buying and bringing home a Tinkerer’s Workshop does not replace the NPC service.

If you plan to combine this accessory with another one, finish the combination first. A modifier on an ingredient is not carried over to the result; a new one is determined when the combined item is made. Avoid spending repeatedly on ingredients just before combining them.

Decide first whether you want defense or offense

An accessory modifier adds a stat to the item’s base effect. The stat that improves depends on the modifier, even for the same accessory.

GoalModifier exampleAdded effect
Add defenseWarding+4 defense
Increase attack damageMenacing+4% damage
Increase maximum mana for magicArcane+20 maximum mana

For example, if you are taking frequent hits and first want to survive longer, consider defense. If you can avoid hits but take a long time to defeat enemies, consider increasing damage. No one type is correct for every piece of equipment or play style.

Do not interpret +4 defense as “damage taken is always reduced by 4.” This comparison is about the stat added by the equipment.

An increase to maximum mana also does not instantly refill all the mana you have spent. Read the modifier description rather than assuming that a different stat increase gave you the improvement you wanted.

Set a budget and inspect each result

Reforging does not let you choose a modifier by name and guarantee it. The result is random, and can be less suitable for you than the current modifier.

  1. Choose one accessory you plan to keep using.
  2. Decide how many coins to reserve for purchases and other preparations, then set a spending limit for this attempt.
  3. Talk to the Goblin Tinkerer, select Reforge, and check the target item and displayed price.
  4. After reforging, read the modifier and its effect description.
  5. Stop if you get an effect you are satisfied with or reach your budget.
  6. Take the accessory back and equip it again.

The price changes based on factors such as the item’s value, its current modifier, and NPC happiness. Check the displayed price every time rather than assuming the next attempt will cost the same as the first. You do not have to keep clicking until you have spent all your money just because you calculated a price.

If you want defense, you do not have to aim for the highest value immediately; you can choose to stop at +2 or +3. Prioritize keeping enough money to buy tools you need and continue your next expedition.

Check the equipment slot if the effect is not active

To receive an accessory’s added stats, equip it in a slot that provides its effects. Leaving it in your inventory or placing it in a vanity Social slot does not provide the same effect.

  1. Check the item name and description after reforging.
  2. Put it in a regular accessory equipment slot.
  3. Make sure it is not in a vanity slot.
  4. If you chose defense or maximum mana, check the corresponding stat.

Some information accessories have functions that work while carried, but do not confuse those with a modifier’s stat increase.

You cannot reforge one accessory repeatedly to stack each previous modifier. If its modifier changes from defense to offense, the new effect replaces the old one; they do not both remain.

Separate causes when you cannot change it or keep clicking

SituationCheck first
Cannot find the option at a workbenchTalk to the NPC and select Reforge
Cannot select armorOrdinary armor is not a reforge target; distinguish it from accessories
Cannot reforge an accessoryCheck whether it is an excluded item such as a Music Box or a Doll
The price changed for the same itemCheck its current modifier, NPC happiness, and displayed price
The stat did not change after reforgingCheck that it is in a regular equipment slot, not inventory or a vanity slot

In version 1.4.5, a short animation plays when an item gets its best modifier, and the button pauses briefly to help prevent you from rerolling it accidentally. If it does not respond immediately, do not assume it is broken; read the result first and then decide whether to continue.

Sources and references

Questions and contributions

Share questions, corrections or play reports. Only approved posts for this article and language appear here.

Submit for review

Do not include personal details, passwords or private information about others. Text only. Publication and replies are not guaranteed.