Even if the candles do not all light during the Year 3 evaluation, you do not need to start your farm over. Add more achievement points, then offer a Diamond at the shrine to request another evaluation. After all four candles light, interact with the shrine again to claim the reward.

This guide covers PC version 1.6, single-player, and no mods. It cross-checks evaluation conditions and rewards against a community-edited wiki; the event was not tested in-game. It focuses on getting back on track after the first evaluation, not the dialogue during the event.

First check the number of candles at the shrine on your farm

Grandpa’s Shrine is in the northwest of the farm. The first evaluation happens on Spring 1 of Year 3. If you are short of points at that time, you can still improve the evaluation by continuing to play.

The goal is four lit candles, which require at least 12 points. You do not need to complete every category. Take stock of what you have already done and plan your next steps around points you can still earn.

If all four candles are already lit, check whether you have claimed the reward before farming more points. Seeing the evaluation and having the statue in your inventory are separate steps.

Choose achievements that fit your current farm

Some of the evaluation conditions include the examples below. This table is an excerpt to help choose what to work on, not a complete list of every evaluation point.

Example achievementEvaluation points
Reach 50,000g in total earnings1 point
Reach a combined level of at least 30 across the five standard skills1 point
Reach level 10 in all five standard skills1 additional point beyond the condition above
Obtain the Skull Key1 point
Obtain the Rusty Key1 point
Complete the Community Center1 point
Attend the Community Center completion ceremony2 additional points

Total earnings are not the money currently in your wallet. There are higher earning thresholds too, so the 1 point for 50,000g in this table is not the full set of earnings-related points. Community Center completion and attending its ceremony count separately. Do not count these Community Center points as earned on the Joja route.

To decide what is within reach, first write down what remains to finish. For example, if you have progressed through the mines, you might work toward a key; if you have made many donations, you might focus on the Museum; if your usual routine has raised your skills, you might build on those levels. This is a way to organize unfinished goals, not a guaranteed fastest route by number of days.

See Museum donations and rewards for the Rusty Key condition. Before taking on a new goal, also check whether you forgot to claim a reward for something you already completed.

Prepare a Diamond and request another evaluation

After adding achievements since the first evaluation, prepare one Diamond. Keeping it separate from gems you plan to sell helps prevent accidentally giving away the one you set aside. If you already use the machine, see how to collect from and replace items in a Crystalarium.

  1. Check that you have received the first evaluation and note the current candles.
  2. Review the achievements you have added since then.
  3. Bring a Diamond to the shrine on your farm.
  4. Offer the Diamond at the shrine to request a new evaluation.
  5. Advance time and check the candles after the evaluation.
  6. When all four candles are lit, interact with the shrine to claim the statue.

The reevaluation is usually the next day, but the sources also mention delays until after loading or a season change. Do not assume it failed just because the candles do not change at the moment you offer the Diamond. There is no need to offer another Diamond before checking whether the evaluation has registered.

Claim the Statue Of Perfection after the fourth candle lights

The reward is the Statue Of Perfection. After confirming all four candles are lit, you must interact with the shrine. To avoid missing the claim, check that the statue has actually entered your inventory.

When placed, the statue produces 2–8 Iridium Ore each day. It does not directly produce Iridium Bars. Plan for the ore and the processing equipment separately; collecting it as part of your daily farm routine can make it easier to manage.

This guide does not include old statue-duplication methods. Since methods were patched in 1.6 and later, do not treat actions such as filling your inventory and breaking the statue as required steps for claiming the reward.

Do not confuse it with the reward for 100% Perfection

GoalReward and main output
Four candles from Grandpa’s evaluationStatue Of Perfection: Iridium Ore
100% PerfectionStatue Of True Perfection: Prismatic Shard

The Statue Of True Perfection is a separate reward claimed from the perfection tracker in Qi’s room on Ginger Island. Offering a Diamond at Grandpa’s Shrine does not satisfy the requirements for 100% Perfection.

To progress island completion, see the island exploration and Perfection checklist order. First distinguish whether you want the statue that produces ore or the separate statue awarded after reaching 100%, and the next goal becomes clearer.

Sources and references

Questions and contributions

Share questions, corrections or play reports. Only approved posts for this article and language appear here.

Submit for review

Do not include personal details, passwords or private information about others. Text only. Publication and replies are not guaranteed.