Decide whether to harvest fish or change species

For solo PC1.6 from 1.6.4 onward, without mods, with an existing pond of ordinary fish such as Sturgeon. Have a Fishing Rod and inventory room. Legendary fish, special non-fish residents and pre-1.6 handling of remaining fish are outside scope.

GoalAction and what remains
Remove a few fishFish them out; species and completed capacity expansions remain
Remove all, then return the same species laterStop after fishing them out; zero fish still retains species and expanded capacity
Change to another speciesUse Empty Pond in the management menu; species and capacity progress return to their initial state

A Golden Animal Cracker boosts pond output. Resetting removes that bonus permanently and does not refund the cracker. Do not confuse this with harvesting fish. If you intend to continue with the same species, favor leaving the pond unreset.

A golden produce bucket is the visible marker of a pond treated with a cracker.

Recover first, reset only when needed

  1. Check the current state. Collect produced items first and inspect species, population, capacity and cracker status. Keep your replacement fish safely in a chest or inventory.
  2. Fish out the residents. Cast into the pond to retrieve them individually. There is no fishing minigame, but casting spends energy, so allow time and energy during the day.
  3. Verify zero population and your inventory. Confirm the fish reached your inventory. If returning the same species, stop here and do not reset the menu.
  4. Inspect the pond only if changing species. With default PC controls, right-click to open management and select Empty Pond. Before executing it, confirm that losing capacity upgrades and the cracker bonus is acceptable.
  5. Add the new fish and verify. Close the inventory menu, hold the replacement fish and right-click the pond. Check its new species/population, then rebuild capacity through that species’ requests.

Fish taken out are normal quality; silver, gold or iridium quality from insertion is not returned. Use a chest instead for high-quality delivery or gift fish. Fishing them out grants no Fishing Collection entry or fishing XP, and consumes no bait.

Zero fish but a rejected species, or no growth

SymptomCheck and response
Another species is rejected at zeroFishing out leaves the old setting; for a species change, review losses and reset
You want to put the same fish backDo not reset; add the original species within capacity
The quest exclamation mark disappearedRemoving fish during a request makes the pond less than full; refilling with the same species to capacity resumes that request
An empty pond neither grows nor producesThere is no starting fish; add a normally reproducing species and wait
The old population no longer fits after resetCapacity expansions were reset; complete requests for the new species again

Completing a capacity request does not instantly fill the pond. Tiger Trout do not reproduce, so do not expect removed individuals to replace themselves. Different species do not all grow on one universal schedule.

Returning to the old species does not restore lost upgrades

In 1.6, remaining fish flop out when a pond is reset rather than vanishing. Do not rely on that as safe bulk retrieval: this guide has you fish them out first and verify inventory. Do not apply the older version’s behavior to this scope.

You can return to the original species after resetting, but capacity requests and the cracker effect do not restore automatically. To preserve both, choose fish-only retrieval without a reset from the beginning.

For building a new pond and processing Sturgeon Roe, see the pond and Caviar setup (Japanese). Decide whether each fish is for selling, processing or returning, and keep the last resident you will need.

Sources and references

Questions and contributions

Submissions are currently paused. You cannot enter or send a post until reception resumes.

Posting rules and data storage