Reaching Combat level 10 alone does not finish unlocking trinkets. First reach level 10 in every skill, earn Mastery experience, claim the Combat reward, then equip a trinket you find in its dedicated slot. Check its effect before deciding whether to use the Anvil!

Separate level 10, claiming the reward, and equipping

Entering the Mastery Cave requires level 10 in all 5 skills. Experience earned afterward advances Mastery; when you can claim a reward, choose the Combat pillar in the cave.

Current situationWhat to check next
Only Combat is level 10Are the other 4 skills also level 10?
All 5 skills are level 10Has Mastery progressed far enough to claim a reward?
You can enter the caveHave you claimed the reward at the Combat pillar?
You claimed Combat MasteryCheck the dedicated equipment slot and Anvil recipe
You own a trinketIs it equipped, rather than just sitting in your inventory?

See your first Mastery and Farming rewards for entering the cave and how experience counts. If you chose Farming first, choose Combat when your next reward becomes available. Also check the Special Items & Powers screen to confirm that you claimed the Combat reward.

This page does not explain how to redo your Farming reward choice. Start by confirming that you claimed the Combat reward, then move on to equipping your next item.

Explore after unlocking and equip one you find

After claiming Combat Mastery, many trinkets can be found from enemies in places such as the Mines, crates and barrels, or treasure chests in Skull Cavern. These are random finds, so do not plan around a guaranteed drop after a set number of attempts. There are also purchase exceptions such as Magic Hair Gel.

We suggest starting somewhere you normally explore and can return from safely. Unlocking trinkets does not make a first trip deep into Skull Cavern mandatory.

  1. Confirm that you claimed Combat Mastery.
  2. Prepare food and a way home, then explore.
  3. When you find a trinket, read its name and effect.
  4. Put it into the unlocked dedicated equipment slot on the inventory screen.
  5. Check whether it suits your purpose somewhere you can easily return from.

Even identical trinkets cannot be stored together in a stack. If keeping one for comparison, make room in a chest and distinguish the one currently equipped from the one in storage.

Check whether the effect suits your goal before reforging

Putting a trinket into the Anvil without reading its effect spends materials before you know what you want to change. Decide first whether you want healing, to stop enemies moving, or a different appearance.

ExampleWhat to check first
Fairy BoxIts healing purpose and displayed level
Ice RodIts freezing purpose and displayed interval and duration
Frog EggWhether the companion suits your gathering or slaying goals
Items that cannot be reforgedExclude them from your Anvil plans

Enemies eaten by the frog drop no items and do not count toward quest kills or monster-slaying goals. Consider this when choosing equipment for days spent collecting enemy materials or advancing kill counts. Do not assume all companions work the same just because they defeat enemies.

This check is not a ranking of the strongest equipment. Choose one use case; if the effect is sufficient, keeping it unchanged remains an option.

Count Anvil crafting costs separately from each reforge

Claiming Combat Mastery unlocks the Anvil recipe, which costs 50 Iron Bars to craft. Each reforge consumes 3 Iridium Bars from your inventory.

PurposeWhat you need
Craft one Anvil50 Iron Bars
Reforge onceAn eligible trinket and 3 Iridium Bars
Budget for two attempts6 Iridium Bars, separate from crafting costs
Materials to keep unusedSupplies reserved for other equipment or tools

Interact with the Anvil while holding a reforgable item to proceed. Basilisk Paw and Magic Hair Gel are ineligible. Before repeating the same action because an effect did not change, check that the item can be reforged.

We suggest an initial limit of one attempt and 3 Iridium Bars. Do not bring materials needed for your next equipment and plan to keep trying until a good result appears.

Reforging is random: compare the result and stop

Reforging rerolls attributes such as performance. It does not always make an item stronger, so note the current display before using the Anvil and compare after retrieving it. If you already have a good item set aside, you can keep that one and try a spare for comparison.

A Fairy Box's level changes its healing interval and amount, but the fairy's appearance is unrelated to level and cannot be changed at the Anvil. In contrast, a Frog Egg's changing color is a visual difference, not a functional upgrade. Assess cosmetic spending separately from spending to improve performance.

ProblemWhat to check again
No equipment slot or no trinket findsHave you claimed Combat Mastery?
No Anvil recipeClaiming the cave's Combat reward
Cannot reforgeIs the item ineligible, or are you missing 3 Iridium Bars?
Less improvement than expectedIt is a reroll, with no guaranteed increase
Only the appearance changedWhich elements can change for that item

Review the result and stop at your original budget. Do not assume you can freely restore the old attributes; finish this round of work by deciding what to equip for your next trip.

Sources and verification scope

The Mastery Cave, Trinkets, and Anvil pages on Stardew Valley Wiki were checked for the equipment slot and acquisition after claiming Combat rewards, Anvil materials, and reforging costs, exceptions, and randomness. This covers PC 1.6, solo, without mods. Setting a budget first and storing a comparison item are editorial suggestions. Complete drop formulas, full attribute tables, optimal equipment rankings, all patch differences, and in-game behavior have not been tested.

Sources and references

Questions and contributions

Share questions, corrections or play reports. Only approved posts for this article and language appear here.

Submit for review

Do not include personal details, passwords or private information about others. Text only. Publication and replies are not guaranteed.